ࡱ > R T Q 5@ R F bjbj22 2N X X , H & 8 8 $ & h h " U W W W W W W $ R Z! 6 { ! D { D D ` D D U U n i D D i \ 0?t? u 6 i 0 i ! . ! i D D D D ! n i Z @ 4 4 h { { D " [v6q
S_NsXf[vTf[W@x
v U_
MR
,{ Nz 6qvV`NsXf[vtQw
N06qvV`
N0N6q:N8h_vsXf[vtQw
N0sXf[tQwveǸof
,{Nz [6qv[~
N0[6qv$Ny[~
N0[~N a'`Ƌ0e)R[O0RQ(W aw
N01gIQ\o[Ry_TNeQ_[~vƋT RekT
V0[~Nsaf[؏S
N06q~vf[aIN
,{ Nz \O:N[[av6q
N06qv_
N06qv_v[Q
N0v_
V0[NLu\O:NHTs'`NLu
N06qvaIN
,{Vz 6qhQ N*NS hQev_
N0[f[N6qhQ
N0S ^Jv6qhQ_
N0jm+oef[z/g-Nv6qhQ`~
V0sX9eiЏR-Nv 6qhQ ;N _
N0S_NsXOb;NINv;N _
mQ0^P[N6qhQ
,{Nz 6qhQvyf[f
N0yf[(W6q[-Nv\O(u
N0[z/gv#kO`N`
N06qhQvyf[f
V0ybċTU\g
,{mQz ^_v6qf[
N0[$Re/fS `$R
N06qvb__vTvv'`
N0 a_
V06q
N0^_l gSsNUONv N
,{Nz ?Y6q
N06qvm1Y
N0[/Tt'`vyb$R
N0[sN;NINz/gvb
V0͑eSs6q
,{kQz \g+Ywm~6q
N0\g+Ywm~ ``vsaf[
nn
N0\g+Ywm~vf[SO|
N0\g+Ywm~6q
,{]Nz -NV6qf[vTf[W@x
N0S[[6qhQv/ec
N0y[[6qhQv/ec
N0Q[[6qhQv/ec
MR
NS_NsXf[sQN6qvQS bNV~N-NYf[S
NsQN6qv NN gNh'`v ``0ُyxvz\bN&^eQNsQN6qTvmv `KN-N0=\{~ǏNvS_p悄vc"}v^_N Rekvbg FO,gv~yv^
NasT@wbNsQN6qTv `v~~ vS [S/f:NbNvۏ Nekc"}cON N*N_vW@x0
S_NsXf[sQN6qvxvz /f(W^8^
N TvtW@x
NۏLv0SbNNofTsOĉRI{ N|R[E]\OvN[N(WQ NN'YY/f(W O~vf[t̀of-N]\O0ُyf[HQnxz Nyf[hQ N[NQ Pُyf[hQSċN6qv[Nf6q USIlTёP[/f$Ny[hQ
N Tvi_ USIl/feSNLuvi_
Nb:N6qyf[vi_ ёP[_N_N/feSNLuvi_FOSN N>PTNb:N6qyf[vi_0Tz/gI{i_1\PUSIl N7h /f^\NeSNLuvi_ [Nvnxz g]v8nbĉR bN
NPe[ёP[/fSP[^pe:N7 9 vё^\7hSe[Tz/gv'`(0 sXyf[[NՋVPyf[[nx[ёP[/fSP[^pe:N7 9 7hnxzv'`( v^9hncُyvhQSaϑ6qNirv[N
eۏ u`|~-NS[Tt :_(unfMT|vpegt6qir N _QN6qhQvp0(WNN weg d[z0W wg*N6qir [S/fNv FO/fb[>e0R u`|~-NS w [1\/fvYg[(Wg*N u`|~-NN6q/fNv HN1\\[>e0Rf'Yv u`|~-NS[ g~ N[OSs[/fv0 ُynfMT|vp[N-NV O~Tf[v^
NL u0-NV O~ ``-NvvsQ `~bvsQ;NIN( c o r r e l a t i v i s m ) ck(W_wVEf[/gLuvSmStQ V:N[&{TN u`yf[TϑP[Rf[:NNhveyf[v `~!j_0FO/f Yg u`yf[(unfMT|vp Y}Y0Wʑ6qirvNeۏ N*Nf'Yv u`|~-N wtSɉ_[/fve NǑ(uN`7hvNhQ euN_N/fǑ(uN O~f[@bS
YLpvNb__vĉ_0` N
N Tv0We/f N Y
Ne0WSbcƉ҉eg w $\vQ/f Yz0Rfؚbf'Yv u`|~v҉^eg w0Nd[z0Wb@\0W w
N&{Tb__ĉ_v6qir N N*Nf'Yv|~bzzeg wtS/f&{Tb__ĉ_v bN[dkmO
Nuf:yꁫ01udk bN gN Ny[hQ
N TNsXyf[[T u`f[[vt6qve_ bYNyKN:Nf[e_0 cgqُyf[e_ 6qirKN@bN/fv V:N6qir[hQ/fNꁫ T NvX[(W [N/f
NS͑
Y
NSk
N
gNNUOOnce gi_vt0ُyf[e_N u`f[[vnfMT|e_R}YvS VdkSNS_0WyKN:N[hQd[ze_09hnc u`f[vnfMT|_ bN^N6qirN6qirKNvsQ|-NSt6q9hncf[v[hQd[z_ bNS grReNirNNirKNvTysQ| \Nir w\ONir,ge MbSs6q01\PbN]~cQǏv7h u`f[vt㉹e_ ( * 0 H J Z ` t z
^ ` B D J d # . 3 6 6 ,7 7 7 (8 F8 hf: 6] hf: hf: o(U
hf: CJ j hf: 0J CJ U
hf: CJ o(hf: 5CJ \o(hb 5CJ \ j hS1 hb 0J <UaJ hS1 hb \aJ o( hS1 hb CJ aJ o(hS1 hb aJ hS1 hb aJ o( 4 ( 4 6 < > f | 4 l
(
>
$ a$ gdb
WDd ` gdb gdb $a$gdb > @F rF F >
@
j
* , J f | . 0 J \ v d WDd ` gdb
WDd ` gdb gdb
$
&
F
d
x $ l. / H1 3 B4 T6 ` d 7$8$9D H$WD ` $ d 7$8$9D H$` a$ gdb [Nc:y6qirvNfsQeg0
/f
NS[INv S gbNǏi_t㉄vlxX MbSsNirv0ُy/fYdkv0N[Yi_ NNbN
NS~[ N*N gnx[Qmvi_06q1\HTsQُye 'Y ُ/f NyO NyYCQKN Ny)YA|KN06qirKN@bN/fhQv v^
N/fV:N@b g6qir&{T T Nyb__ /fV:N@b g6qir/f T7hv
N N7h0W01\6qir/f[hQNꁫ T Nv҉^eg [Nv/f
NSk0
NSR~0[hQs^I{v0
S_k*NNirRRNꁫ T NveP [YUO Y#kON[hQ
N TN]vNir ُvnx/f N*N^8^Vv0[
NN/f N*Nf[ N/f N*N&Otf[0Vdk (WOncf[e_[6qvt-N _6qOS+T Ny&Ot;N _0ُy;N _1\/f(WNSbrzv Te YUO
\͑Nv _N1\/fYUO wckcSYCQv0ُ*Nv[(1\/f(W;N _*NN1uv TeYUO YIYL>yOl;N0
N^P[:NNhvS[Tf[/fk*NNirb:Nk*NNir,g uN uvk*NGrkb:Nk*NGrk,g
NN|_iregʑdkir
NN|_eegʑdke ُ7h1\OmegǏS0*gegT̑vSR EQRHTsNir,gvaIN EQRHTsN u,gvaIN N 0R
e(WvXLu0^P[vُy ``_0RNy[v~bTSlb0FOe/f^P[؏/fy[ SbR0W㉳QNYUO\NirNMRT]SVe
N NvsQ|-Nd[zQegNONirb:NNir,gv [Nl gbR0W㉳QYUOs^I{0W[_NꁫhQ6q
N TvNirv0
Q[v_U` ``e0RNKN-N \NƉ:Nb[Uv N*Neb0~Ǐُ7hvt N1\Ob:NbT_v0S
NS؏S:NbvGY0
6qhQ1\S+Tُ7h Ny#kO_0W
\͑Nv&Ot;N _ b S g(Wُy#kO_0W
\͑Nv&Ot u;m-N bNMb Y wckeu0R6qvYCQKN0
,gfN NNzvQ[f~Nevb__Sh(W NNf[/gBg_bOeƖ
N vQ-NSb N a t u r a l B e a u t y a n d a R e v i e w o f C h u a n g T z u s A e s t h e t i c s J o u r n a l o f t h e F a c u l t y o f L e t t e r s , T h e U n i v e r s i t y o f T o k y o , A e s t h e t i c s , V o l . 2 5 , 2 0 0 0 0
06qvsNaIN 0
0Tf[ 02 0 0 0 t^,{1 g 0
06qhQSvQyf[f 0
0U^'Yf[f[b 0 2 0 0 1 t^,{4 g 0
0 6qhQ N*NS hQev_ 0
0WS^f[bf[b 0 2 0 0 2 t^,{1 g 0 A l l N a t u r a l T h i n g s A r e E q u a l l y B e a u t i f u l NN O~ ``N6qt VEf[/gOe 2 0 0 2 t^ VS] 0
06qhQNyf[Tf[v҉^ w 0 6q yf[N f[/gOe 2 0 0 3 t^ SN 0ُ̑yr+Rc0Rv/fMRVEf[O;N-^0e,g NN'Yf[vPOPO(gYecTV^N'Yf[v4g?emYec 1uNNNvR b g:gO(ueTVY TLN~N,gfNv;Np0 a" \&OyrA r n o l d B e r l e a n t Yec~bc~c0WʑNNaS\~gvsXf[KNv:S+R =\{,gfN;NNaS\~gv ``0 a"eyrfR i c h a r d S h u s t e r m a n Yeccbla?Yv gsQ `` ,gfN,{7 z1\/f[?Y gsQ ``vNxvz0 a"^gKQ( D a v i d B r u b a k e r ) YeccbsQlhm- ^v `` yr+R/fhm- ^v ``N-NVSxQf[vsQT =\{b g~l(WُebZPQNxvz FO[hm- ^ ``vN ^8^ gRNbt㉰saf[f[T\g+Ywm~sQN6qv0 a"VؚI{Ye"V~b Nt^vxvz~9 b geƖ-N|RNN-NVSxQf[-Nv6q ``vxvz0 a"SN'Yf[QHr>yv[\,gfNReQQHrR $\vQ a",gfNvs)RRHQ u V:NNv~]\O%_eN,gfNv
N\:w0 a"SgYecT1go_Yec gRbNN,gvxvz0 gT a"bvYP[zy Ygl gyYvcwO ,gfN_Ns(Wz)R1?z0
,gyvxvz_0RNYe萺Ne>yOyf[͑pxvzW0WWё0Ye͑pf[yWё0NSSN'Yf[R^NLu NAm'Yf[~9vDR (Wdk Nv^h:y a"0
m_
2 0 0 4 t^9 g1 6 eNSN'Yf[yV
gsQz/g\O:NeSNLuvi_SvQNyf[xvz-Nvi_v:S+R G e o r g e D i c k i e , D e f i n i n g A r t : I n t e n s i o n a n d E x t e n s i o n , }P e t e r K i v y e d . , T h e B l a c k w e l l G u i d e t o A e s t h e t i c s ( M a l d e n , O x f o r d , a n d C a r l t o n : B l a c k w e l l , 2 0 0 4 ) , p p . 4 5 - 6 2 0
kY W\e u`f[cSsteSO0T0vNOV03z['`I{I{& & evpencv^l g&T[ /f͑ecb\[N>eۏN N*Nf'Yv u`e,g-N N 9eSNbNvT03z[I{_ ObN(WNMR w
Nv0We wN H o l m e s R o l s t o n , b!, I s T h e r e a n E c o l o g i c a l E t h i c ? , E t h i c s , 1 9 7 5 , v o l . 8 5 , p p . 1 0 0 - 1 0 1 0S NMO u`f[[Wyr)R_NcQ (W gُy( u`f[) wƋvN w Ny_NT0We [:ONُywƋvNeg S/feaINvBgqN V a l R o u t l e y , C r i t i c a l N o t i c e o f J o h a n P a s s m o r e , M a n s R e s p o n s i b i l i t y f o r N a t u r e , A u s t r a l a s i a n J o u r n a l o f P h i l o s o p h y , 1 9 7 5 , v o l . 5 3 , p . 1 8 3 0
kY 'k2mW
TvIlf[Bg_
0 NSirlQb 0B u l l e t i n o f t h e M u s e u m o f F a r E a s t e r n A n t i q u i t i e s , N o . 7 2 , S t o c k h o l m , 2 0 0 0 1\N ͑e `e g-NVvvsQ[[ R e c o n s i d e r i n g t h e C o r r e l a t i v e C o s m o l o g y o f E a r l y C h i n a :NQHrN Nyr
R0
2 0 0 4 t^5 g8 e \&OyrS'YTf[| {1\NNaS\~gKNv;N]_TNc _0RvVT{/f1 0aS\~g;N _(W6q[Tz/g[KNZPQ%N `> b> h> > @ BC D >F @F RF TF VF lF nF pF rF F F F gdb h]h &`#$ WD` nWD `n WD ` ` F8 9 f9 : : ; ; 0; T; ; ; > > > > ? ? ? @ ܴ A A A A A A $ B B B T b c q 5 C R e x % . ; J V W f w g < _
u Z ? @ r )
$ ' @ 0 @ 0 p @ 0 p @ 0 p @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 0 0 p 0 p 0 p @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 @ 0 p 0 ̿ My0 0 My0 0 My0 0 @ 0 @ 0 My0 0 0 3 @ 0 0 l% F8 fF F % & >
T6 F $ F ! ! ! 3 d 3 r 3 \ 3 . 3 T. 3 " ' ' 8 *urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsCity 9 *urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace " $ 2 5 = @ S T a c f h p s # % 4 7 B E Q T d e w z $ % - 0 : = I L U W Z ] e h v y f g ; < % 3 ^
_
: < u Y Z
" # $ % & ' ( ) * + O P Q R S T U V x y z { | } ~ > @ g
( , . / Q U W X \ & - 5 6 Q R i q { |
7 > D o p v z M T [ ] ^
p q t ( / 0 1 2 3 \ ]
' 6 : ` a p s
" = C o t ` c
' 3 3 s s 3 s 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 s 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
'
' s y p s y p s y p s y p s y p s y p s y p s y p s y p p e n g f f: b > T c q 5 C R e x % . ; J W f w @ )
$ ' @
& P P . U n k n o w n G z T i m e s N e w R o m a n 5 S y m b o l 3& z A r i a l ; [SO S i m S u n 3 z T i m e s q h QU F t L ( L ( - ! ) , . : ; ? ] } & 6"0000 0 0
00000 =@\]^ ( [ { 0
0 00000;[ 2
` H ( ? b s y p s y p Oh +'0 H
( 0 8 @ s s syp yp Normal syp 22 Microsoft Word 10.0 @ {4 @ r!@ &W? L ՜. +,0
X ` l t | icr (
A
! " # $ % & ' ) * + , - . / 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 : ; < = > ? @ B C D E F G H J K L M N O P S R o o t E n t r y F /t?U D a t a
( 1 T a b l e 0 ! W o r d D o c u m e n t 2N S u m m a r y I n f o r m a t i o n ( A D o c u m e n t S u m m a r y I n f o r m a t i o n 8 I C o m p O b j f
F Microsoft Word ĵ
MSWordDoc Word.Document.8 9q